Shared Library, Shared Albums and hidden photos

Apple's pages do not say how hidden photos behave in a Shared Library, so do not assume they are held back. What Apple does say is that everyone in a Shared Library can add, edit and delete its content, and that Shared Albums are not covered by Advanced Data Protection. Keep sensitive photos out of both.

What Apple documents about a Shared Library

  • Up to five other people can join, so a library has up to six people.
  • "All participants can add, edit, and delete content in the Shared Library."
  • Items you contribute move out of your Personal Library and into the Shared Library.
  • The creator can remove a participant or delete the library at any time. Participants can leave at any time.
  • Deleted items go to Recently Deleted, and only the person who contributed an item can delete it from there.

Apple's Hidden album page and Shared Library page do not mention each other. We cannot tell you whether a hidden photo can be moved to a Shared Library or how it would appear.

Shared Albums

Shared Albums are a separate feature. Apple says Shared Albums do not support Advanced Data Protection, so that content stays under standard protection with Apple-held keys, even if you turned the setting on.

What you can do

  1. In Settings, Apps, Photos, Shared Library, check who is in the library and what is being shared. Apple's page also lists the "Sharing from Camera" option there, which sends camera photos straight to the Shared Library; check it is off if you do not want that.
  2. Keep photos you want private in your Personal Library, and switch the library view to Personal if you want to see only yours. The view switch moves between menus on different iOS versions, so use the path your phone shows.
  3. If a photo has already gone in, ask a contributor or remove yourself from the library after reading Apple's options for keeping copies.

What this does not cover

A vault app does not change who is in your Shared Library, and it cannot pull back something participants already have.

Where the photo isWho can see it
Personal LibraryYou, and your other devices if iCloud Photos is on
Shared LibraryEvery participant, who can also edit and delete it
Shared AlbumThe people you invited
Hidden albumApple does not say how it interacts with the Shared Library

Related: is the Hidden album secure, are iCloud Photos end-to-end encrypted, the answer do hidden photos sync to iCloud and Hidden album or vault app.

Frequently asked questions

Can my family see my hidden photos in a Shared Library?

Apple's pages do not say. Everyone in a Shared Library can add, edit and delete its content, so keep sensitive photos out of it.

Are Shared Albums end-to-end encrypted?

No. Apple says they do not support Advanced Data Protection.

Can I leave a Shared Library?

Yes. Apple says participants can leave at any time and choose to keep a copy of everything or only what they contributed.

Sources

StrongRoom is a free iPhone app, coming to the App Store.

Free for iPhone. Pro is optional. What Pro changes.

Coming to the App Store. See what version 1.0 includes.